Skip to main content

Rifts in the communist movement


The Ukraine war has divided communists around the world. The worst position is that of the Communist Party of Britain (CPB) which calls it “Putin’s war” and demands an unconditional Russian withdrawal from Ukraine – which is also NATO’s demand . They also denounced what they called “Russian military adventurism” in a joint statement the CPB sponsored that only attracted the support of nine other communist and workers’ parties.

CPB election leaflets in the May local elections all carried the following statement "Communists opposed Putin’s invasion of Ukraine from the first hour. Putin and his cronies are opposed to Socialism and Communism. They stole what belonged to the Russian people. We say: Stop the war, Start the peace".

It didn’t do them any good. Five of their seven candidates got less than a hundred votes apiece. The others got the majestic sums of 119 and 126 votes. The CPB’s Blackheath Westcombe hopeful was beaten by the Official Monster Raving Loony candidate by 125 votes to 79.

Communist Party of Greece

A more significant section of the movement led by the Communist Party of Greece (KKE) argues that Russia is an imperialist country and that the war is simply a quarrel between two imperialist blocs. This is a view rejected outright by the Communist Party of the Russian Federation (CPRF) that leads the opposition in the Russian parliament and is the largest communist party in Russia. The second biggest, the Russian Communist Workers Party (RCWP), which does think Russia is “imperialist”, nevertheless supports the Russian intervention in support of the people of the Donbas.

In March the KKE sponsored a joint statement that said “the decision of the Russian Federation to initially recognise the “independence” of the so-called “Peoples’ Republics” in Donbas and then to proceed to a Russian military intervention, which is taking place under the pretext of Russia’s “self-defence”, the “demilitarisation” and “defascistisation” of Ukraine, was not made to protect the people of the region or peace but to promote the interests of Russian monopolies in Ukrainian territory and their fierce competition with Western monopolies”.

The New Communist Party of Britain (NCP), along with the majority of the members of the Solidnet group it was sent to, including the CPRF and the RCWP, refused to sign it. But some 40 others did.

In April the Secretariat of the Communist Initiative (ECI) , a KKE-inspired European communist forum, issued a draft statement for May Day to the same effect. A number of parties, including the NCP and the RCWP, proposed amendments which forced the Secretariat to water-down the final statement.

But a few days later the Secretariat issued a statement for Victory Day on 9th May without any consultation that said “the Second World War, like the first one and the current war in Ukraine, is a result of imperialist contradictions and competition for the redivision of markets and spheres of influence. The people pay a heavy price for the condemnable Russian invasion of Ukraine, like the previous US-NATO-EU interventions that led to it: dead and wounded people, refugees, extremely expensive energy and fuel, and high prices”. This has led to the resignation of the Hungarian Workers Party from the Secretariat.

Meanwhile the KKE has launched public attacks, in their daily paper and online, on the stand of the CPRF and the RCWP in support of the Russian intervention which have been rebuffed in equally robust terms by the leaderships of both Russian parties.
Labels:

Comments

  1. AnonymousJune 29, 2022 at 2:27 PM

    This is the response of the RCWP to the KKE https://actofdefiance.wordpress.com/2022/06/28/international-department-of-the-central-committee-of-the-rcwp-on-the-class-understanding-of-the-struggle-against-fascism-and-the-mistakes-of-the-leftism-of-the-greek-comrades/

    ReplyDelete
  2. AnonymousJune 30, 2022 at 9:36 AM

    Communists worldwide should be united and not split over the role of Russia in the Ukraine.

    The CPB in Britain is not speaking in the name of many communists and working class activists, when it tries to equate Russian nationalism with US led imperialism.
    The normally strictly Marxist Leninist KKE by condemning Russia is siding up with the imperialists and Trotskyists and revisionists.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Ukraine peace talks: seeing through the blizzard of confusion and spin

by Theo Russell Since the historic summit in Alaska between Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin and their top level ministers, our media has been flooded by a tidal wave of deception and diversion, alongside a new campaign of Banderite inspired anti-Russian demonisation. The entire world recognises – with the possible exception of senior British military and intelligence chiefs – that NATO has lost the war in Ukraine, leaving total defeat or a negotiated settlement the only possible ways to end the conflict.  As of now, Trump’s position is that a comprehensive, lasting peace deal is preferable to a ceasefire, and that secondary sanctions are off the table. As we know Trump can flip his policies on a whim, but there is reason for optimism that genuinely he wants a settlement in Ukraine. This shift in Washington has thrown Europe’s leaders into a state of panic. The leaders of the ‘Coalition of the Willing’ are facing a political disaster on a massive scale, and as a result they are desp...
Post a Comment
Read more

Nato press gangs in Ukraine

by a Kiev observer   American imperialism continues to ruin all states that call themselves democratic and independent. In fact, many countries have already lost their independence. Some lost it along with their currency; others by giving away their army. The White House continues to hide its financial greed behind the illusion of possible global protection. At the same time, regular workers and civil servants have difficulty understanding what is really behind the foolish statements of “collective security” peddled by the bourgeois media. An example of the realities that every worker will face in the near future is in the war in Ukraine. Despite all the statements we hear from Western media, the war in Ukraine was started by imperialism, and the reason it did it was to make more money. This war, however, has also exposed the steps and measures that modern capitalist governments under Nato command have taken in Ukraine, and shows what they will do in their own countries in the futu...
Post a Comment
Read more

Ukraine: A Search for Identity and Freedom

by John Maryon Russians, Ukrainians and Belarusians are predominantly from the East Slav sub-group of the Slavic people.  Crimean Tatars form an important ethnic group of the population of Crimea.  The fertile lands of mineral rich Ukraine were for centuries shared between the Poles and the Mongols.  By 1500 the Ottoman empire had expanded and taken over South East Ukraine and Crimea.  In 1654, following years of conflict with the Polish Lithuanian Commonwealth, the Cossack leader of Ukraine pledged allegiance to the Czardom of Russia in exchange of protection. Russian influence increased and in 1797 Catherine the Great established the port city of Odessa and the region became an important part of the Russian Empire.  Today most people have heard of the Crimean War, Florence Nightingale, Balaclava and the Charge of the Light Brigade.   It was an imperialist conflict for Middle East influence between Russia and an alliance of France, Britain and Turkey....
1 comment
Read more